| Roundtable: Who is Watching the Watchdog |
| Roundtable Presentation 318 to be held in Suwannee 21 on Thursday, Nov 12, 1:40 PM to 3:10 PM |
| Sponsored by the Non-profit and Foundations Evaluation TIG |
| Presenter(s): |
| David Bell, University of Pittsburgh, dab34@pitt.edu |
| Abstract: Nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) that serve to hold policy makers accountable must also be held accountable. As the influence and level of NGO activity has grown, so have the questions about motivation and legitimacy. Of the various accountability mechanisms, voluntary networks represent a potent, voluntary alternative. This paper will explore 'who is watching the 'watchdog'' through a comparative analysis of voluntary NGO accountability networks. A framework for evaluating voluntary networks as an accountability mechanism is introduced to stimulate research. It is argued that a valid construct for evaluating voluntary networks can inform network selection and use by NGOs. This can result in an effective response to challenges of legitimacy, advancing organizational learning, and providing accountability to various stakeholders. As with democracy; however, effectiveness is significantly influenced by the acceptability of the network's product by civil society, as well as civil society (including key funding sources and donors) encouraging NGOs to participate. |